All or Nothing Rule (Archive)

Unlike the MA program, which allows people to choose which eligible household members want coverage, MinnesotaCare requires certain eligible family members to apply and enroll. This provision is known as the ”All or Nothing Rule.”

The All or Nothing Rule ensures that all household members have equal access to coverage. It is also a way to prevent families from choosing to insure one child and not another or from insuring only the household member with the greatest coverage need.

All or Nothing Criteria.

Other Health Care Coverage and the All or Nothing Rule.

Citizenship and Immigration Requirements and the All or Nothing Rule.

When Not to Apply the All or Nothing Rule.

Top of Page

All or Nothing Rule Criteria

The All or Nothing Rule requires that:

l  All eligible children in a household who do not have other health care coverage must enroll if one child enrolls.

l  All eligible spouses or parents in a household who do not have other health care coverage must enroll if one spouse or parent enrolls.

l  Parents may enroll only if the eligible children in the household who do not have other health care coverage enroll.

n  Parents may choose not to enroll.

n  Eligible children may enroll regardless of whether the parents enroll.

Note:  If a child who is required to provide or apply for a Social Security number (SSN) fails to do so, he or she and all other children and adults in the household are ineligible until the SSN is applied for or obtained. For information on verifying SSNs and applications for SSNs, see Social Security Numbers.

Example:

Bob, Mary and their two children, Sam (age 10) and Anna (age 3) apply for MinnesotaCare. They do not have any other health care coverage. The Health Care Application (HCAPP) lists Social Security numbers for everyone but Anna.

Action:

Bob, Mary and Sam meet all of the eligibility requirements; Anna does not meet the SSN requirement.

Do not approve coverage for Bob, Mary, Anna and Sam until a SSN is either applied for or obtained for Anna.

Note:  Any adult in a household with another adult who is required to provide or apply for an SSN but fails to do so is ineligible until the SSN is applied for or obtained.

Example:

Troy, Denesha and their two children, ages 15 and 13, apply for MinnesotaCare. They do not have any other health care coverage. The HCAPP lists Social Security numbers for everyone but Denesha.

Action:

Do not approve coverage for Denesha or Troy until Denesha supplies her SSN or applies for her SSN.

Approve coverage for the children because parents are not required to enroll with their children.

Top of Page

Other Health Care Coverage and the All or Nothing Rule

Do not require people who have other health care coverage to enroll in MinnesotaCare based on the All or Nothing Rule.

Example:

Bud and Mabel, a married couple with no children in the home, apply for MinnesotaCare. They are both U.S. citizens and permanent Minnesota residents. Bud is disabled and covered by Medicare Parts A and B. Mabel has no health care coverage.

Action:

The All or Nothing Rule would require Bud to apply for MinnesotaCare if Mabel is determined eligible. However, Bud cannot enroll because he has Medicare, which is considered other health care coverage. Mabel can enroll on her own, with a household size of two. Count both her and Bud’s income and assets.

Example:

Judy and Greg apply for MinnesotaCare for their two children. Judy and Greg each have health care coverage through work. Neither employer offers dependent coverage. The children have no health care coverage.

Action:

Both children must enroll if they meet all other eligibility requirements. The children will have a household size of four, which includes Judy and Greg and the children themselves.

Example:

Alice applies for MinnesotaCare for her son, Troy, who requires regular care for chronic ear infections. She does not want coverage for herself or her daughter, Mavis, because they have no ongoing medical needs and Alice feels she can’t afford the premium for three people. All three household members meet MinnesotaCare eligibility requirements. No one in the household has other health care coverage available.

Action:

Due to the All or Nothing Rule, Mavis is required to enroll because Troy, her brother, is eligible to enroll. Alice is not required to enroll. Troy and Mavis have a household size of three, which includes themselves and their mother.

Example:

Abe and Mary apply for MinnesotaCare for themselves and their two children, Kevin and Kyle. Mary is pregnant and covered by MA. Kevin is also on MA. Abe and Kyle are not covered on MA because of excess income. They have no other coverage available. Mary and Kevin want to stay on MA.

Action:

Mary and Kevin are not required to enroll in MinnesotaCare because they have other coverage through the MA program.

Because Kevin has other health coverage, Kyle can enroll separately from him.

Abe is not required to enroll but may enroll separately from Mary as long as Kyle enrolls.

The household size is four.

Top of Page

Citizenship and Immigration Requirements and the All or Nothing Rule

Noncitizens who do not have a status that qualifies for MinnesotaCare are ineligible. Do not apply the All or Nothing Rule to household members if another member is ineligible due to immigration status. See Health Care for Noncitizens.

For U.S. citizens, apply the requirement to document citizenship and identity as follows:

l  All children and all adults in the household are ineligible if a child who is required to provide documentation of citizenship and identity fails to do so.

l  All adults are ineligible if an adult who is required to provide documentation of citizenship and identity fails to do so.

l  See Cooperation with Documentation Requirements before denying or closing eligibility based on the All or Nothing Rule.

Top of Page

When Not to Apply the All or Nothing Rule

Do not apply the All or Nothing Rule when a household member does not satisfy an eligibility factor that is unrelated to enrollment in other health care coverage.

Ineligibility of household members due to these eligibility factors does not affect the eligibility of other members who meet eligibility requirements. These factors include but are not limited to:

l  Cooperating with obtaining medical support.

n  Caretakers who fail to cooperate without good cause are ineligible for MinnesotaCare.

n  Do not limit eligibility for the spouse and children because the caretaker is ineligible due to cooperation with medical support.

l  Cooperating with applying for MA.

n  Certain people with disabilities are required to apply for MA and become ineligible for MinnesotaCare if they fail to do so. See Disabled Adults Without Children.

n  Do not limit one spouse’s eligibility because the other spouse did not comply with the disability determination.

Top of Page